Last updated: 02 Jan 2020

The Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters (Review) in 2020

ORIJEN High-Protein Dry Dog Food

ORIJEN High-Protein Dry Dog Food

Honest Kitchen Human Grade Organic Grain Dog Food

Honest Kitchen Human Grade Grain Dog Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Grain Free Wet Dog Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Grain Free Wet Dog Food

Show contents
Dr Tracy Douglas
Published 13:15 pm

Picky eating can be super stressful for dog owners. You want the best for your pooch and when they don’t eat, it can cause some serious alarm. While a lack of eating can often signal a more pressing medical concern and should thus be discussed with your vet,  it is sometimes simply just about your pooch being picky. In these cases, you will need to opt for food that inspires their taste buds and makes them excited to eat again. The following list explores some of our best picks for fussy eaters and is bound to tantalize their taste buds. As always, our list contains an array of options for different budgets and dietary needs.

The Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters


The first pick on our amazing list for best dog food for picky eaters, is an excellent product by Orijen. This high-protein dog food boasts only brilliant quality and is grain-free, premium quality dry meat dog food. Flavours are bound to drive your dog wild and consist of free-run-chicken, cage-free-eggs, and wild-caught salmon. The company use only regional ingredients that they know and trust, for extra safety and ultimate wellbeing and this brand is biologically appropriate. In simple terms, it nourishes the dog the way that nature intended. This brand combines top-quality meat with fresh fruit and veggies and is a fantastic choice for anyone who has a picky eater on their hands.

Biologically appropriate

Dry dog food

Free-run-chicken, cage-free-eggs, wild-caught-salmon

Fresh fruit and veggies

Regional ingredients

4.5 lbs, 13 lbs, or 25 lbs bag

  • Brand: Orijen
  • Model: DOR4410-13
  • Weight: 12.9 pounds


Fromm Family Foods seriously care about your pooch and if you have a fussy eater around, this naturally formulated dog food might just be a fabulous choice. Bursting with fresh duck, chicken, whole lamb, veggies, and real cheese, this brand is sure to tantalize their taste buds and infuse ultimate health and nutrition into their diet at the same time. As a family run business, this brand pride themselves on top-quality and customer care. Users have commended this amazing brand on its ability to help pooches with sensitive stomachs and those who are picky eaters, and for its amazing value. Others have commended it for alleviating itchy skin conditions and creating glossy coats. If you’re looking for a family-run brand that you can trust, this might just be the best pick for you.

Family run business

Fresh duck, chicken, whole lamb, veggies, and real cheese

Great for sensitive stomachs

Good value

Helps skin and coat health

33 lbs

  • Brand: Fromm
  • Model: 727520
  • Weight: 4 pounds


Taste of the Wild High Protein Real Meat Recipe Premium Dry Dog Food with Roasted Bison and Roasted Venison

Number 3 on our list of best foods for picky eaters is an amazing pick by Taste of the Wild. True to their name, this premium dry dog food brand, pride themselves on using real meat. Their food boasts roasted bison and venison and an optimum amino-acid profile for ultimate health and wellbeing. This pick is super protein rich and thus the perfect food for building muscle and supporting skin and coat health. It is also filled with antioxidants to strengthen immunity and overall health. This highly digestible food is packed with probiotics and works hard to support gut and digestive health. Since the gut is said to be the seat of overall bodily health, this will aid in boosting the immune system. If your pup is a picky eater, chat to your vet about this brand. As always, it’s best to get a specialist opinion when changing their foods and always opt for a vet-approved brand.

Dry dog food made with real meat (roast bison and venison)

Rich in protein and antioxidants

Family owned brand

  • Brand: Taste of the Wild
  • Model: 9567
  • Weight: 28 pounds


Number 4 on our list is a brilliant pick by Wellness Natural Pet Food. This wet dog food is a superb pick for fussy eaters and since it’s a wet food, will add extra deliciousness to every meal. You can simply pop it over dry food or opt to only feed them wet food. This awesome pick comes in a pack of 12 and boasts variety, delicious flavors including turkey, chicken, beef, lamb, and salmon, and super amazing value. It is free from artificial colors, preservatives, flavors, and grain.

Choice of lamb, chicken, turkey, salmon, or beef

Wet dog food

Grain free

No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives

  • Brand: Wellness Natural Pet Food
  • Model: 89402
  • Weight: 11.6 pounds


Number 5 on our list is an excellent choice by Blue Buffalo. This high protein, grain-free adult dry food might just be the perfect pick if you have a fussy eater on your hands. Loaded with real chicken, antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals, this pick is bound to promote ultimate health and wellbeing and satisfy even the fussiest of furry friends. This mix is also packed with sweet potatoes and peas for extra health and taste and customers can choose between chicken, duck, or salmon. It’s also rich in omega 3 and 6 fatty acids and thus wll promote overall skin and coat health and ultimate wellbeing.

Chicken, duck, or salmon flavor with sweet potato and peas

Adult dry dog food

4.5 lbs, 11 lbs, or 24 lbs

Grain free

Rich in omega 3 and omega 6 fatty acids

  • Brand: Blue Buffalo
  • Model: 840243105342
  • Weight: 24 pounds


Number 6 on our list of best foods for picky eaters is a fantastic choice by Wellness Core Natural. True to their name, this brand aim to promote total health and wellness, and might just be the best pick for any fussy eaters. This delicious food is made with deboned turkey and chicken and thus aims to tantalize their taste buds, all the while offering a nutrient dense food. This protein focussed nutrition aims to promote optimal development and offers a balanced every-day diet for your best pal. It’s grain free and free of all artificial flavors, colorants, and preservatives.

Grain-free dry dog food

Deboned turkey and chicken

Free of colorants, flavorants, and preservatives

4lbs, 12 lbs, or 26 lbs

  • Model: 88403
  • Weight: 26 pounds


Lucky number 7 on our list is a fantastic pick by The Honest Kitchen. This pick offers grain-free, balanced nutrition to your pooch and is bound to delight them with its chicken and turkey and real vegetable recipe. This brand is true to their name and are truly honest when it comes to their wholesome ingredients. This pick contains no artificial flavors, wheat, corn, soy or meat by-products, and thus is a healthy dog food that will enhance your pup’s wellbeing and suit even the fussiest of eaters. The omega fatty acids do wonders in supporting their coats and overall skin quality and the high protein levels will ensure great energy and vibrancy. Users have commended this pick for making coats look super shiny, its great value, and helping pups who have itchy skin.

Dehydrated organic grain dog food

Turkey, chicken, and real veggies

4lbs, 12lbs, or 26 lbs

Rich in omega fatty acids

High in protein

  • Brand: Honest Kitchen
  • Weight: 10.5 pounds


Next up is a brilliant grain-free wet dog food by Merrick. This delicious pick is sure to entice even the fussiest of eaters and includes tasty ingredients like chicken, red new potatoes, peas, carrots and red apples. They all come in a scrumptious gravy and might just be the food that gets your fussy dog to eat. Like many of the amazing picks on our best dog food list, this brand is void of artificial flavors, colorants, or preservatives. The high protein content of the deboned fish, chicken, meat or poultry are a great source of protein and will ensure that your pup is able to exert optimal energy. Added to this are the amazing levels of omega 6 and omega 3 fatty acids which aid healthy skin and coat health. Customers have praised this pick for getting their fussy pooches to eat and have commended it for its amazing nutritional value and variety of healthy ingredients.

Grain-free wet dog food

No artificial flavors, colorants, or preservatives

Omega 3 and omega 6 for coat health

High protein – deboned chicken, fish, poultry, and meat

Added veggies

  • Brand: Merrick
  • Model: 00175
  • Weight: 11.4 pounds


Number 9 on our fantastic list of best foods for your picky eater, is a premium quality dry dog food by Rachel Ray Nutrish. This amazing brand combines fantastic, locally produced quality with great value. The number one ingredient is US farm-raised chicken, and this is a brilliant source of protein that is bound to support healthy muscle development and overall energy levels. It also contains natural probiotics which aid with effective digestion and gut health. This brand is free from colorants, preservatives, wheat gluten, and artificial flavor. Rachel Ray truly believes that ‘food is love’ and this product is no different. This brand boasts optimal health, high nutritional value, and is sure to get those picky eaters eating again.

Premium dry dog food

Us raised chicken and veggies

Probiotic rich

Free from colorants, preservatives, wheat gluten, and artificial flavors

  • Brand: Rachael Ray Nutrish
  • Model: 184303
  • Weight: 39.7 pounds


The last pick on our list of best foods for fussy dogs is an excellent choice by Blue Buffalo Wilderness. This amazing high-protein wet dog food is perfect for optimal muscle development and amazing energy levels. It’s grain free and includes delicious chicken and beef to get those fussy eaters eating again and is mineral and vitamin rich for added health. To ensure extra safety and the promotion of amazing health this pick is free of wheat gluten, colorants, artificial flavors and preservatives. Cans come in an array of flavors including salmon, trout, turkey, duck, and catfish. This diversity of flavor is sure to excite your pup and keep them interested in their next meal.

High protein wet dog food

Comes in an array of diverse flavors (chicken, turkey, duck, catfish, salmon, trout)

Rich in minerals and vitamins

Grain free

  • Brand: Blue Buffalo
  • Model: BLU00588
  • Weight: 9.4 pounds

Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters Buying Guide & FAQ

Is Your Dog a Picky Eater?

While some dogs might naturally be picky eaters, it is often a result of their humans feeding them too many treats or human foods from the table. Dogs are simple creatures and will usually happily eat the food that their human gives them. If your dog has become fussy over time and now refuses their food that they once happily lapped up, you might have a picky eater on your hands.

When to Worry About Your Picky Dog

If your pup suddenly stop eating and this is accompanied by stomach upset, vomiting, rapid weight loss, or extreme fatigue then you might have a more serious medical issue on your hands. If this is the case, get them to your vet asap, as it might be more than your pup simply being fussy.

If your pup won’t eat their meals, but has no other worrying symptoms, and will happily eat treats or table scraps, they might just be a fussy eater or the particular food you are feeding them might not make them feel their absolute best. Follow the tips below to see If you can encourage them to eat again.

What to Look for in a Dog Food for Picky Eaters

Opt for foods that are rich in flavor and vet approved. It is best to go for a grain-free food that is void of artificial colorants, flavors, and preservatives. Some pups might prefer wet dog food as this might be a tastier pick and tantalize their taste buds a little more than dry varieties.

How to Encourage Your Picky Eater Dog to Develop Healthier Eating Habits

  • Try to limit the number of treats that you give your pup in-between meal times and avoid feeding them human food straight from the table. If you choose to cook them meat and veggies add this into mealtime.
  • Place their food down for 30 minutes and then remove it. They need to learn that mealtime is a definitive time and that if they don’t eat their food then and there they will have to wait for their next meal.
  • Place their food in a comfortable area where they feel safe.
  • If all else fails, opt to change their food. Do this gradually to avoid stomach upset. Simply add a quarter of the new food into their old food and gradually increase the amount every few days.

Our Top Pick

While we adore all our top foods for fussy eaters,  we have opted for this amazing pick by Orijen as our best pick as it combines incredible quality with great value. This high-protein dog food is grain-free and thus encourages optimal health and wellbeing. The delicious favours are sure to drive your  fussy dog wild and include free-run-chicken, cage-free-eggs, and wild-caught salmon. Orijen use only regional ingredients that they know and trust, and this brand is biologically appropriate. In easier terms, this food nourishes your pup the way that nature planned. This brand combines top-quality protein with fresh fruit and veggies and is an awesome choice for anyone who has a picky eater on their hands.

The Best Dog Food for Hypothyroidism (Review) in 2020
The Best Dog Food for Kidney Disease (Review) in 2020
Best High Fiber Dog Food (Review & Buying Guide) in 2020
The Best Low Sodium Dog Food (Review) in 2020
The Best Dog Foods for Shedding (Review) in 2020
Best Dog Food Toppers (Review & Buying Guide) in 2020