Dog collars provide a more effective way of controlling and preventing flea and tick infestation in our pets, especially our dogs. While these devices are essentially laced with chemicals, they are nevertheless slowly released to help repel and kill fleas, ticks, lice, and even mosquitoes. In case you’re wondering what are the 5 best flea collars for dogs in 2017 are, then read on and you’ll be treated to an excellent array of flea protection and superb safety for your dog.
5 Best Flea Collars For Dogs
- 1 5 Best Flea Collars For Dogs
- 1.1 Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs by Bayer
- 1.2 ProGuard+ Flea and Tick Collar with Winter Guard by SOZO Safe Pet
- 1.3 UltraGuard Plus Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs by Hartz
- 1.4 Scalibor Protector Band for Dogs Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs by Intervet
- 1.5 EasyDefense Flea and Tick Tag by Only Natural Pet
1Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs by Bayer
When it comes to ectoparasite control, there are only a few brand names that veterinarians all over the world trust. Bayer is one of them. While K9 Advantix II and Advantage II provide very formidable solutions to the flea and tick infestation problem, these products are somehow shunned away by some members of society primarily because they believe these products are too harsh for their dogs’ hepatobiliary system. It is perhaps for this reason that Bayer decided to come up with a longer lasting solution to the flea and tick menace. The Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs is clearly the most trusted when it comes to wearable anti-flea technology based on the close to 7,400 super satisfied dog owners on Amazon.
One of the most important mechanisms of action of Seresto is that it effectively repels adult fleas and ticks as well as other critters like mosquitoes which can also harbor deadly microorganisms. When these critters are repelled, they will not have the opportunity to transmit the microorganisms that they carry into the dog’s bloodstream. This helps protect the dog from the many parasites that are carried by these organisms which can have an effect on the heart of dogs. While Seresto is effective in repelling bugs, it is more effective in killing these organisms including lice and the larvae of fleas.
The therapeutic effectiveness of Seresto is published at 8 months although we have read several reports indicating that it could actually be much longer than that, sometimes lasting even up to a year. While there are no clinical studies to either prove or disprove these claims, it is a lot better to stick with the recommendations of the company.
Slipping the Seresto over your dog’s neck is as easy as slipping any other dog collar. The good thing is that it actually fits any type of dog. It’s non-greasy and will not emit any offensive odor. Bayer recommends not sleeping with your dog beside you, however. This is not to say that it is not safe for us. However, to be on the safe side, it’s better not to get in contact with your dog’s collar for a prolonged period of time. The Seresto dog flea collar is also waterproof so you don’t need to remove it even if your dog will be swimming or will be taking its regular bath. However, if you do intend to allow your dog to swim for more than once every month, it is crucial to understand that the therapeutic effectiveness of Seresto substantially decreases to just 5 months. Regular baths are known to have no effect on the therapeutic effectiveness of Seresto.
What We Like about It – Bayer has been in the pharmaceutical industry since 1863. With more than 150 years making a variety of medicines that have helped man fight many diseases, this expertise has been dutifully extended into the field of animal care. Seresto’s superb 8-month protection is proof of this longstanding commitment to quality products.
2ProGuard+ Flea and Tick Collar with Winter Guard by SOZO Safe Pet
Ectoparasites like ticks and fleas have a very peculiar behavior that can be rightfully called human-like. Well, technically, all warm-blooded organisms do this. During the winter, these organisms seek warmer locations to thrive. That is why we often see a lot of these pests inside our homes and in our pets during this time of the year. Fleas and ticks typically thrive in warm, moist, and darkened environments especially those that have plenty of organic debris to feed on. Unfortunately, the advent of winter drastically changes these conditions. The environment upon which these organisms have relied on for many months has suddenly turned inhospitable. Like any other organism that’s faced with the prospect of extinction, fleas and ticks will have to relocate often finding the warm glow of our homes very attractive. And when our pets go out to play in the snow, they become the natural transport system for these organisms.
That’s why we need to protect our beloved pets from this menace. The ProGuard+ Flea and Tick Collar with Winter Guard may not have the necessary level of credibility enjoyed by Bayer’s Seresto, but judging from the comments made by customers who have already tried the product, it actually works. It is intended to both kill and repel fleas, ticks, mosquitoes, and lice while also killing flea larvae.
ProGuard+ works in the same way as Seresto. The only minor difference is that the preventative effectiveness only lasts 6 months compared to Seresto’s 8 months. It boasts of a patented Winter Guard system and we can only surmise that this refers to its mix of active ingredients that include tetrachlorvinphos, s-methoprene, and a host of other unnamed ingredients that make up a little less than 85 percent of its formulation.
SOZO Safe Pet recommends not touching the ProGuard+ flea tick collar for prolonged periods as the chemicals of the product may be absorbed by the skin. It is highly recommended that thorough washing be performed if prolonged contact occurred. At any rate, ProGuard+ can be a more practical solution to the flea problem as it is slightly cheaper than Seresto. However, with such an insignificant price difference, we’d rather stay with the Seresto. Nevertheless, for those who would like to save a few bucks, well, ProGuard+ looks promising enough.
What We Like about It – The patented Winter Guard solution is what ProGuard+ is boasting about. Unfortunately, we really couldn’t find a plausible explanation as to what comprises this particular system. Nonetheless, it is an effective solution at a price that is a few dollars lower than Seresto.
3UltraGuard Plus Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs by Hartz
At less than $5 per piece, there are serious questions as to the preventative effectiveness of the UltraGuardPlus Flea Tick Collar for Dogs. It is about 10 times cheaper than ProGuard+ and more than 12 times cheaper than Bayer’s Seresto. But here’s what’s puzzling. UltraGuard Plus has exactly the same ingredients as ProGuard+ but with a longer protection at 7 months. The reviews on Amazon are also mixed with an almost equal number of consumers voting for and against the product. So, what gives?
We probed a little deeper into the mystery and found that it is indeed effective but more on a hit-or-miss basis. We focused on the negative comments and found that most of the negative feedback actually has nothing to do with UltraGuard Plus’ ability to repel and kill fleas, ticks, and other critters. Many of these negative comments were based on, perhaps, the design of the collar itself. One commented about the collar not fitting properly only to find out that it’s more about the concern of cutting the excess collar as a waste of money. Such issues, we believe, don’t relate so much to the product’s ability to repel and kill ectoparasites. These were all minor issues that can be addressed in other ways, we think.
However, it still doesn’t answer the question why so cheap? Obviously it works because of the positive comments saying that it really works, although perhaps not as efficient as Seresto or even ProGuard+. But the point is that, for the really budget conscious, then it’s worth the price. With 7 months of continuous protection and a price that’s ridiculously lower than competition, it would really be more a matter of recognizing your priorities for your dog. Are you willing to pay several tens of dollars to help protect your dog? Or is the price for dog flea collar too steep for you?
What We Like about It – We really cannot explain why UltraGuard Plus is this inexpensive. But for the really cash-strapped dog owner, it should provide a fantastic relief that he or she is able to provide 7 months’ worth of protection for his or her dog.
4Scalibor Protector Band for Dogs Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs by Intervet
Scalibor sounds like the mythical sword of the Arthurian legends, Excalibur. Perhaps Intervet came up with the name to depict a really formidable solution to the dog flea and tick menace. But mind you, Intervet is actually a subsidiary of Schering-Plough, a pharmaceutical company that gave us some of the world’s best anti-allergy medications like Claritin and Clarinex. Schering-Plough merged with Merck & Co. and the animal health products of the two have since been under one name: MSD Animal Health. We really had to emphasize this as we believe, as consumers, you have the right to know who makes the products you give to your pets. Merck & Co. is well-known worldwide and is one of the most trusted names in healthcare. They have an online resource that caters to healthcare professionals including those in animal health. That being said, you can count on the Scalibor Protector Band for Dogs Flea Tick Collar for Dogs to be one of the highest possible quality and preventative effectiveness.
Knowing Merck and Schering-Plough, they will not be using the same active ingredients that competitors use. That’s why they formulated deltamethrin which is as effective as s-methoprene. Studies show that deltamethrin has been proven to be effective in the control of many species of pests and has been one of the most widely used pesticides and insecticides not only in the US but the whole world. It’s effective in the elimination and prevention of household pests such as fleas, ticks, bed bugs, spiders, cockroaches, carpenter ants, and even carpenter bees. Of particular importance is its ability to serve as an active ingredient in the manufacture of insecticides designed to control malaria vectors such as Anopheles gambiae.
Unfortunately, this is where the problem lies. Because of the widespread use of deltamethrin-containing insecticides for a variety of applications, animal care experts are now seeing a growing resistance to the active ingredient. It is for this reason that Scalibor only managed to get 3.7 stars on Amazon because of several dog owners saying it doesn’t work. Here’s the main issue. If you live in an area where deltamethrin had been extensively used as an insecticide, there’s a very strong chance that many of these organisms have already developed resistance to the drug. Organisms that develop resistance simply won’t be affected by that drug anymore; hence, it will still persist. However, if you live in an area where deltamethrin has never been used before or were only used in minimal to moderate amounts, it is highly possible that Scalibor will be a very effective flea tick collar.
What We Like about It – There are serious issues regarding the use of Scalibor owing to its history of extensive utilization and the resulting flea and tick resistance. However, all things being equal – meaning, there is no existing organism resistance to deltamethrin – Scalibor can be a great competitor to Seresto. However, they do have to account for its 6 month active prevention time frame as this is a far cry from Seresto’s 8 months. Nonetheless, for half Seresto’s price and given there’s no resistance, Scalibor is an excellent choice.
5EasyDefense Flea and Tick Tag by Only Natural Pet
Don’t ask us how the EasyDefense Flea and Tick Tag really works. All we can tell you is that there are more people saying it works than those who say it doesn’t. The controversy lies in the supposed holistic technology that the EasyDefense Tag has built-in. Even very satisfied customers cannot really explain how it works. They just know that it is effective since they no longer see fleas or ticks in their pets for months on end. This included customers who lived in flea- and tick- infested areas that it would be nearly impossible to get rid of these pests without using some form of chemical treatment. What gives?
Only Natural Pet recommends attaching the EasyDefense Tag on your dog’s collar. If your canine friend already has a dog tag, the EasyDefense should be placed in the outer position, with the other dog tag nearer to the skin of your dog. The supposed mechanism is that the EasyDefense Tag will utilize your pet’s energy to create and build a natural barrier that will supposedly shield it from pests such as fleas, ticks, lice, and mosquitoes. It doesn’t involve any chemicals such as insecticides or pesticides. Just what energy is being converted into a protective shield, no one really knows. The packaging does not include any explanations as to how such a mechanism works. We also dug deeper for a more plausible explanation but we cannot find any that can be backed by empirical science. What we unearthed is something similar to the Chinese concept of chi or life force which is supposed to protect or shield us from harm. Like we said earlier, don’t ask us how it works but it does seem to work.
This is one of those cases wherein the facts before the outcome are simply too muddled, to confusing to comprehend. Yet, the outcome tells us that it works. Could it be a modern interpretation of consequentialism where the end clearly justifies the means? We’ll never know.
What We Like about It – EasyDefense has a very mysterious way of protecting our dogs from these nasty pests. If you believe such “miracles” or unseen forces exist, then the EasyDefense is for you. If you don’t want to use chemicals or any other harmful substance on your dog that can also affect your health and safety, the EasyDefense is the answer. If you don’t mind paying an additional $20 or so on top of the price of Seresto, then EasyDefense is definitely for you.
How We Chose the Best Canine Flea Collars in Our List
How do you choose a medicine that you know will be effective for you? Unfortunately, there is no easy answer to this as each organism responds to chemicals in various ways. It may be effective for you but not for another person. The same is true with dogs. Certain flea medications may work exceptionally well with certain breeds living in a particular location while these same medications can hardly make a dent on the infestation problem in other breeds and in other locations. The point is that, there clearly is no objective way to ascertain the effectiveness of a medication-impregnated flea tick collar. As such, we can only count on existing literature including clinical studies to make our case of the top 5 dog flea collar products.
Of particular importance is the maximum length of therapeutic effectiveness of these preparations. Since these products operate on the principle of sustained release mechanisms, the longer the therapeutic action, the better it is, and the safer it is for the dog. We also looked at the product’s spectrum of antiparasitic activity. As much as possible, it should not only be able to kill fleas and ticks but other critters as well. We also considered other features in the dog flea collar such as proven therapeutic and safe active ingredients as well as the capability of the product to repel these microorganisms so they don’t attack the dog anymore. Of course, we made sure that these should also be easily worn by any dog breed and size.
Flea Collars are Great But…
We have just shared with you 5 of the best flea collars for dogs in 2017. We know there are some issues about a few of them. The thing is that, this is the reason why we’re giving you these reviews in the first place. We now know how flea collars work. However, a more important issue is how we can control and prevent flea infestation in the first place. This is because, whether we like it or not, fleas and ticks and other pests will always be here and no amount of pesticides, insecticides, or dog flea collars will ever be enough to control them from wreaking havoc.
You see, flea collars are great but they have a definite lifespan. At most, you’ll get a 1 year protection from the EasyDefense. If you don’t believe in holistic treatments, then the 8 month protection of Seresto should do. The point is that these collars will only work up to a certain time. And we are not really getting rid of the source of the problem which is the great outdoors.
Every time our pets venture outside, they run the risk of getting in contact with these pests. During the cold months, these pests will also seek warmer environments. They will be entering our homes. The only way we can solve this problem is by thoroughly cleaning our property, inside out. That means we’ll have to turn our house upside down if we have to and make sure that every little nook and cranny is free of these pests. Outside will be a bit trickier as there are other sources of these pests. Squirrels, opossums, and other rodents typically carry these pests, too. So, even if we do clean our backyard, we must prevent other animals from entering.
That is why flea collars are great but should not be the only solution that we have to use. There are other things we have to do if we really want to minimize the problem of flea and tick infestation.
The Bottom Line
The control and prevention of flea and tick infestation is a tricky subject as it requires a very comprehensive approach that involves environmental management, home management, and pet management. Only when these are adequately met can we begin to see a reduction in pests that endanger our pets. Our 5 best flea collars for dogs should be made as an integral component of this flea control program.
Like What You Read? Please Rate This Article And Let Us Know What Your Thoughts!